Thursday, June 28, 2012

Dietze, The Irish Identity Crisis


“But real adventures, I reflected, do not happen to people who sit at home: they must be sought abroad”  - An Encounter





James Joyce seems to perfectly encompass the struggles and affairs of the people of Dublin in the 20th century during the scorn of Irish nationalism. Torn and stressed from British rule, the citizens are polluted with confusion and disillusion of who they are both on a national as well as individual level. Each generation from youth to adulthood is faced with that looming question which is carried out throughout separate stories in Joyce’s Dubliners. As each short story has its own complications, struggles, and trials; they all come together to form one whole entity, just as the search for identity confined both the individuals there and make up of Ireland as a nation.




As the characters each struggle to figure out where they stand, a reoccurring notion of rebellion is entwined throughout the stories often in the form of leaving Ireland to find their answers.



From the struggles of the young schoolboy in "An Encounter": “I began to hunger again … for the escape for which those wild sensations seemed to offer me.” In "A Little Cloud” when Little Chandler's timidity is holding him back from his dreams of being a poet and concludes he is a ‘prisoner for life’ both within the confines of his homeland and within himself. To “Eveline” when the young woman turns down a new life in Argentina with her lover, to stay trapped in a life she isn’t happy in, confused and unsure. In "Counterparts"“his body ached for him to do something..." "A Painful Case"“His life rolled out evenly – an adventurous-less tale” and "Grace" which presented religious struggle and the men's longing to repent and reinvent themselves.

And lastly, in "The Dead", when Gabriel tells Miss Ivors of his annual cycling tour in France and Belgium, she sternly questions why he would leave his own country and scolds him for such an idea. He retorts saying he’s “sick of his own country," and felt “his own identity was fading out into a grey impalpable world: the solid world itself, which these dead had one time reared and lived in, was dissolving and dwindling.”




As the characters in Dubliners, search for their identity in the discontent of their nation; I hope we all allow Dublin to open our minds and teach us something new about ourselves. 


5 comments:

  1. I like your pointing out that, in the quest for national and personal identity for these characters, there's an underlying sense of revolution. Great images too.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I really like that you wrote about the characters consistent identity crisis. I think that many different events factor into why these people have this mindset. Joyce makes a point in choosing a few specific events that led up to characters dissatisfaction with their lives. Joyce highlights the Irish's dislocation from their national identity. He attributes circumstances such as the potato famine, religious prejudice, and the desire to uphold tradition, to the dispassionate tone of his characters. Overall, I think Joyce exposes the paralysis of the Irish and their struggle with their identity. In a sense theses stories strip these people of their facades and reveal their vulnerability.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I loved your psychological analysis here. After finishing the book, I found that the stories dealing most profoundly with identity crises (Eveline, A Little Cloud, etc) really stuck with me more than anything else. I think these stories have aged well and translate just as genuinely in 2012 as they did in 1914.

    ReplyDelete